Assessment
Professional Grading Rubric
This rubric is based on the criteria that professional editors and film schools use to evaluate editing work. Use it to self-assess every major project throughout the year. A score of 3 ("Proficient") represents competent, professional-level work. A score of 4 or 5 represents the work of an advanced or exceptional editor.
Pacing & Rhythm
Storytelling & Narrative
Technical Proficiency
Sound & Music
Color & Image
Creativity & Voice
Scoring Guide
24–30
Exemplary
Professional or near-professional level work
18–23
Advanced
Strong work with clear areas of excellence
12–17
Proficient
Competent, solid work ready for professional contexts
6–11
Developing
Significant progress but key areas need further development
Below 6
Foundational
Return to core principles and practice fundamentals